Norris Frank Patrick Allan Pickard Donat Raymond Conn Smythe Lloyd Turner
1959 Gracze Jack Adams Cy Denneny Tiny Thompson
1960 Gracze Buck Boucher Sylvio Mantha Jack Walker
Działacze Charles Adams John Kilpatrick Frank J. Selke
1961 Gracze Syl Apps Charlie Conacher Hap Day George Hainsworth Joe Hall Percy LeSueur Frank Rankin Maurice „Rocket” Richard (trzyletni czas oczekiwania) Milt Schmidt Oliver Seibert Bruce Stuart
Działacze George Brown Paul Loicq Fred Waghorne
Sędziowie Chaucer Elliott Mickey Ion Cooper Smeaton
1962 Gracze Punch Broadbent Harry Cameron Rusty Crawford Jack Darragh Jimmy Gardner Billy Gilmour Shorty Green Riley Hern Tom Hooper Bouse Hutton Harry Hyland Jack Laviolette Steamer Maxwell Billy McGimsie Reg Noble Didier Pitre Jack Ruttan Sweeney Schriner Bullet Joe Simpson Alf Smith Barney Stanley Nels Stewart Marty Walsh Harry Watson Rat Westwick Frederick Whitcroft Phat Wilson
Działacze Frank Ahearn Walter A. Brown Fred Hume James D.