Alexandra2012/2013Bradford City 2–3 Burton Albion Northampton Town 1–0 Cheltenham TownBurton Albion 1–3 Bradford City Cheltenham Town 0–1 Northampton TownBradford City 3–0 Northampton Town2013/2014Burton Albion 1–0 Southend United York City 0–1 Fleetwood TownSouthend United 2–2 Burton Albion Fleetwood Town 0–0 York CityBurton Albion 0–1 Fleetwood Town2014/2015Plymouth Argyle 2–3 Wycombe Wanderers Stevenage 1–1 Southend UnitedWycombe Wanderers 2–1 Plymouth Argyle Southend United 3–1 Stevenage(po dogrywce)Wycombe Wanderers 1–1 Southend United(Southend wygrało 7-6 w rzutach karnych)2015/2016Portsmouth 2–2 Plymouth Argyle AFC Wimbledon 1–0 Accrington StanleyPlymouth Argyle 1–0 Portsmouth Accrington Stanley 2–2 AFC Wimbledon(po dogrywce)AFC Wimbledon 2–0 Plymouth Argyle2016/2017Blackpool 3–2 Luton Town Carlisle United 3–3 Exeter CityLuton Town 3-3 Blackpool Exeter City 3-2 Carlisle UnitedBlackpool 2-1 Exeter City2017/2018Lincoln City 0-0 Exeter City Coventry City 1-1 Notts CountyExeter City 3-1 Lincoln City Notts County 1-4 Coventry CityCoventry City 3-1 Exeter City2018/2019Newport County 1-1 Mansfield Town Tranmere Rovers 1-0 Forest Green RoversMansfield Town 0-0 Newport County (Newport County wygrało 5-3 w rzutach karnych) Forest Green Rovers 1-1 Tranmere RoversNewport County 0–1 Tranmere Rovers(po dogrywce)2019/2020Colchester