Louis Blues 2011 – Roberto Luongo i Cory Schneider, Vancouver Canucks 2010 – Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils 2009 – Tim Thomas i Manny Fernandez, Boston Bruins 2008 – Dominik Hasek i Chris Osgood, Detroit Red Wings 2007 – Manny Fernandez i Niklas Bäckström, Minnesota Wild 2006 – Miikka Kiprusoff, Calgary Flames 2005 – nie przyznano z powodu lockoutu 2004 – Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils 2003 – Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils i Roman Čechmánek i Robert Esche, Philadelphia Flyers 2002 – Patrick Roy, Colorado Avalanche 2001 – Dominik Hašek, Buffalo Sabres 2000 – Roman Turek, St. Louis Blues 1999 – Ed Belfour i Roman Turek, Dallas Stars 1998 – Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils 1997 – Martin Brodeur i Mike Dunham, New Jersey Devils 1996 – Chris Osgood i Mike Vernon, Detroit Red Wings 1995 – Ed Belfour, Chicago Blackhawks 1994 – Dominik Hašek i Grant Fuhr, Buffalo Sabres 1993 – Ed Belfour, Chicago Blackhawks 1992 – Patrick Roy, Montreal Canadiens 1991 – Ed Belfour, Chicago Blackhawks 1990 – Andy Moog i Rejean Lemelin, Boston Bruins 1989 – Patrick Roy i Brian Hayward, Montreal Canadiens 1988 – Patrick Roy i Brian Hayward, Montreal Canadiens 1987 – Patrick Roy i Brian Hayward, Montreal Canadiens 1986 – Bob Froese i