Buffalo Sabres 2009 - Tim Thomas, Boston Bruins 2008 - Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils 2007 - Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils 2006 - Miikka Kiprusoff, Calgary Flames 2005 - Nie przyznano trofeum z powodu lockoutu 2004 - Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils 2003 - Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils 2002 - José Théodore, Montreal Canadiens 2001 - Dominik Hašek, Buffalo Sabres 2000 - Olaf Kolzig, Washington Capitals 1999 - Dominik Hašek, Buffalo Sabres 1998 - Dominik Hašek, Buffalo Sabres 1997 - Dominik Hašek, Buffalo Sabres 1996 - Jim Carey, Washington Capitals 1995 - Dominik Hašek, Buffalo Sabres 1994 - Dominik Hašek, Buffalo Sabres 1993 - Ed Belfour, Chicago Blackhawks 1992 - Patrick Roy, Montreal Canadiens 1991 - Ed Belfour, Chicago Blackhawks 1990 - Patrick Roy, Montreal Canadiens 1989 - Patrick Roy, Montreal Canadiens 1988 - Grant Fuhr, Edmonton Oilers 1987 - Ron Hextall, Philadelphia Flyers 1986 - John Vanbiesbrouck, New York Rangers 1985 - Pelle Lindbergh, Philadelphia Flyers 1984 - Tom Barrasso, Buffalo Sabres 1983 - Pete Peeters, Boston Bruins 1982 - Billy Smith, New York Islanders